Viewed in
2007
Premise
In 1930's aristocratic England, a young girl's misunderstanding causes her older sister and her lover to be separated and he is forced into fighting World War II.
Who should watch
Those who like epic romance type of movies, but with a strong stomach for the war scenes.
Thoughts
Note: I have not read the novel.
The last act with Vanessa Redgrave totally saved this movie from mediocrity. I could not fathom all the accolades it has received. In terms of epic, separated-by-war love stories, 'A Very Long Engagement', was much more interesting and emotional and romantic.
The most annoying part for me was the music. Except for a handful of exceptions, a score should never stand out. Throughout the movie, sounds from the story, such as the typewriter would 'blend' into the score. While my film maker persona thought it was clever, my film watcher persona found it pretentious and distracting. I think because of that, I also disliked the 'Rashomon'-like and time-jumping storytelling.
I did find two things I really liked. James MaCovey ruled. He was completely convincing as a leading man, and I look forward to seeing more of his future acting. The other gem in the movie was the twist in the last act with the great Vanessa Redgrave. I didn't even know it was her. Her performance and presence flipped the film upside down and caused me to forgive the rest of the story. Almost.
What I would change
Not sure.
