Viewed in
2009
Premise
Based on 'the greatest graphical novel of all time', a drama about a parallel universe in which flawed super heroes affect the 1985 world.
Who should watch
Fans of comic books.
Thoughts
I found it emotionally underwhelming.
The story was intriguing, as it was a parallel universe that required a lot of work on my part to remember that. Even though the plot took place in 1985, there were a lot of flashbacks to historic moments since 1940. This was one of my favorite parts about the movie, as they put their own twists to some of the most well-known images in American history, such as the hippie putting the flower in the soldier's gun.
I liked that all the characters were complex and had human flaws. Even the god-like Dr. Manhattan's flaw is akin to a workaholic neglecting their loved ones. In addition, they were mostly smart characters, who behaved because of their motives, not because of the plot. I loved the part when a character points out 'I am not comic book villain who spills my secrets. My plan succeeded 35 minutes ago.'
Special effects were top-notch, as expected. They helped give the movie the feel of a graphic novel, and I am sure they allowed the film makers to make literal translations of iconic scenes and imagery from the original source.
The stupendous thing is, that a well-written story about flawed human characters failed to touch my heart. Most of the actors looked like they were just going through the motions. One could argue that it was the seriousness of the story, but to me they all looked like stone statues in every scene. Ironically, it was Rorschach, played by Jackie Earle Haley, who resides in a complete mask, who had the most memorable character.
I had just seen 'Frost/Nixon' very recently, and I was mesmerized by Frank Langella's performance as President Nixon. This clearly affected my experience as I had to endure the inferior portrayal of him in this movie by an actor with a prosthetic nose.
Another inexplicable issue I had with the movie was the music choices. They were songs of that time period, but it just seemed too obvious. Maybe it is just a personal preference for me, but I believe pop music should never exist in comic book or fantasy movies.
I admired the story, the characters and the special effects, but I simply did not love any of the characters to like this movie.
What I would change
I know Nite Owl II and Silk Spectre II's love story was supposed to represent the hope of the movie, but man, it seemed so corny in comparison to the bigger, deeper themes brought forth.
Personal
I liked the shout out to '300' during Comedian's death scene. As a David Bowie fan, I smirked when I saw a young Bowie in Studio 54 in a montage. Lastly, I was not disturbed by Dr. Manhattan's blue penis, but 'Dr. Manhattan's Blue Balls' is now a candidate for my next fantasy football team name.
